Comin thro’ the grain

It was only after an hour or more spent in the office of John Lawson, Edinburgh City Archaeologist, pouring over detailed digital maps depicting the Siege of Leith fortifications and ancient pathways to the sea, that I realised we were not alone in the room. John’s office is reached by climbing a steep and winding old town staircase inside the Museum of Edinburgh on the city’s Royal Mile, passed glass cabinets filled with polished artefacts and through creaking, oak timber doors. Within the office, his desk is strewn with lever-arch files, scrolls and hardback books and is enclosed by a fortress of boxes stacked high in cardboard columns. Sitting opposite John at the other side of his desk, I suddenly realised with a mixture of horror and delight that I was surrounded by the medieval remains of 20- 30 of my fellow Constitutional Streeters in boxes.

The box closest to us was labelled skeleton 880 in thick, black marker pen. Carefully lifting off the box top to reveal its packed contents, John inspected various jiffy bags inside containing femurs and fibula as another might enthusiastically explore a picnic hamper of sandwiches packed at home earlier in the day- familiar and yet forgotten about for a while. Most obvious at the centre of the box was the skull. ‘Oh, a woman!’ exclaimed John. He could tell this by the less pronounced brow ridge, vertical forehead and sharp upper margins of the eye orbits. I cradled the smooth, soil-tinted skull of an adult female in my cupped hands and looked into her sightless sockets.

Most remarkable was the whiteness of 880’s remaining teeth, one or two of which had become dislodged and rattled around in the cardboard box like missing pieces from a second-hand jigsaw puzzle. John picked up an incisor and tried inserting it into various vacant slots along her jawline before finding an exact fit. He explained that the absence of refined sugar in the medieval diet accounted for the relatively good condition of her teeth compared to our own modern-day addiction to sugar. Irn Bru and Buckfast being late additions to a sweetened, Scottish palette. And yet in contrast to the sharpness of her pearly-white front teeth, the back molars of 880 woman were noticeably worn-down from a lifetime of grinding grain, the staple diet of old, old Leither. Indeed, still today, Leith Docks imports cargos of grain from Canada and the Baltic states- wheat, oats, barley and rye. The mills, including formerly the Grain Silo at the foot of Constitution Street, thresh the different grains to become animal feed, flour for bread and, if the grain is of sufficient quality, it is syphoned off for whisky distillation.

Forensic experts from the Centre for Anatomy and Human Identification at the University of Dundee are painstakingly undertaking craniofacial analysis to reveal the likely faces of several of the 14th to 17th century Constitution Streeters unearthed during the six months of 2009 Tram work excavations. Some date from as far back as 1315 AD and therefore five years ahead of Robert the Bruce signing Scotland’s original constitutional touchstone, The Declaration of Arbroath.

It total, the remains of nearly 400 men, women and children were found on a previously unknown section of South Leith Parish Church graveyard. There were 302 complete burial sites found and a further 100 individuals in fragments of bones. It is likely that at least 300 additional skeletons were obliterated by utilities maintenance over the preceding years including in the engineering of a Victorian sewage system and 1990s telecommunications cabling.

The Orcadian poet George Mackay Brown described bone as subtle and long-lasting. In my own beach-coming amongst the Uig dunes on the Isle of Lewis earlier in the summer months, I had picked up the skull of a common gull, larus canus, and placed it as a totem to the nature gods on the steps of the Mackenzie sisters’ caravan during a week of walking and reading in which I twitched like a small bird in my sleep, both embracing and wrestling with isolation. The beak-shaped lattice of collagen and calcium followed me home in my rucksack and now keeps watch on a bookshelf over my desk in Leith.

Although generally acidic, the silty soil deep under Constitution Street with its ancient remains of oyster shells provides good drainage and so the perfect long-lasting conditions for preserving bone. The remains found may provide evidence of the nearby medieval hospital of St Anthony’s destroyed in the 16th century but we can’t know for certain because the carpark of a budget German supermarket now marks the spot. Before the construction of what is now known as South Leith Parish Church (St Mary’s Church pre-Reformation), the hospital chapel appears to have been the place of worship for local trades and craftsmen.

None of the graves excavated so far on Constitution Street date later than the last episode of bubonic plague in Edinburgh in 1645 when 2,700 people died in Leith – over half the population of the time. The practice of burying victims in mass graves without coffins beyond the town walls and the burning of all infected premises may account for this gap in Constitution Street burial records. In his Life and Times of Leith book, historian James Marshall details huge cauldrons bubbling on the Links sand dunes for the boiling of infected clothes.

When Constitution Street as the wide thoroughfare connecting sea and city that we know today was first laid out in 1790, the Church of Scotland declared that it knew of no human burial sites on the land. Indeed, the gas mains man who first hit human bone with his pneumatic drill on digging a utilities trench in 2008, before the Edinburgh Trams project, was said to have been somewhat surprised too.

Staring back at me from John’s computer screen was the life-like image of a woman who had lain hidden for over 600 years and is estimated to have been 30- 35, my own age, when she died. Although old for her time, 35 can be an in-between, liminal age for today’s millennial women in the western world. An age where we rightly want to choose to be both mothers and careerists, or neither, but are constantly reminded by the medical profession and advert profiling that 35 is the edge of the fertility cliff from which we must catch our depleting and falling eggs before all is lost to a cold, barren sea.

The title of J D Salinger’s Catcher in the Rye, borrows from the Burn’s poem Comin’ Thro’ the Rye. Salinger’s protagonist, Holden Caulfield, misinterprets the poem to read ‘if a body catch a body’ rather than ‘if a body meet a body.’ In the realms of his dystopian imagination Holden keeps picturing children playing in a field of rye near the edge of a cliff, and him catching them when they start to fall off, like fatalistic lemmings, one by one.

Gin a body meet a body

Comin thro’ the grain;

Gin a body kiss a body,

The thing’s a body’s ain.

This body’s ain avatar on the screen in front of me showed a blue-eyed, fresh-faced woman with long, brown hair and a height of 5”1. Her vital statistics read like an online dating profile. I could imagine that scrolling further, the profile might include a GSOH and that she WLTM someone tall, dark and handsome. I had found a match. Two women sitting face to face across half a millennium of human history in the Leith area of Edinburgh. She was, and I am, linked by faint traces of distant mothers and daughters, connected by shared place not biology- traces now mostly forgotten but every so often, seemingly by chance, re-emerging like a brass etching portrait. Women who laughed, cried, swore, made love, grieved and felt something, briefly, of the messy mix of what it is to be alive. My medieval Constitution Street woman lived at a time when most likely died at 35 from complications in late pregnancy, during childbirth or by catching a fever. The threat from infection was real and ever-present with foreign cargo and crew continuously arriving at the Port, together with poor sanitation and overcrowding in slum housing.

Back at John Lawson’s office at the Museum of Edinburgh, the pixilated women on the screen in front of me had no name. But she would once have had a name of her own and have been known. She would have had a family tree- all the ‘David Copperfield’ crap as Holden Caulfield put it.  None of the 400 Constitution Streeters since rediscovered from the medieval past have names now, only numbers. I was sceptical of the sun-tanned, unblemished skin and the appearance of makeup presented by the facial reconstruction in front of us but John explained that this was due to an artist’s ink work and that other photoshopped results were plainer and perhaps more realistic. He also assured me that many of the Leith faces brought back to life were in fact ‘extremely ugly’ and while he wasn’t in any way suggesting inbreeding, there were several female skulls found with abnormally large foreheads and jaws.

While historians like to tell stories, scientists are in the business of evidential proof. Strontium and oxygen isotopic analysis from Dr Kate Britton at Aberdeen University from a sample of 18 of the Constitution Street bodies indicates that around 80% spent their childhoods in the Leith or Edinburgh area, with the remainder growing up within a radius of 20- 50km. The vast majority of the population died before they reached the age of 30-35 with peaks of mortality occurring in older children aged 7-12. Medieval Constitution Streeters would have been much more in touch with their own mortality than our present-day selves.

Bodies were buried in the Christian tradition of east-west on their backs in closely arranged rows and only a few in coffins. For centuries, our ancient neighbours lay perpendicular and witness to the daily tide of street surf washing north-south, up and down the street only 1.2 meters above- cheek by jowl to the foundations of present-day landmarks on the street, places like Kirkgate House, Carolyn Designer Florist, the Alan Breck Lounge and, perhaps most appropriately of all, the Boneyard Tattoo studio where owner Ritchie has a particular penchant for tattooing skulls. He boasts 86 skulls of various sizes adorning his own body and says he is ‘dead against’ the planned trams extension.

The dig at Constitution Street was one of the largest and most important urban excavations of human remains ever undertaken in Edinburgh and Scotland in recent years. When the contested Edinburgh Tram works likely return to complete the route from the city centre to Leith and Newhaven, former residents of the street will once again turn in their graves when the tarmac is sliced open, trenches cut, utility services dislodged and old faces revealed to new onlookers and the penetrating light of an expansive, northern sky. The shifting, liminal land did, in fact, not lay still. As all of the graves from recent digs predate the formal layout of the street in 1790, there are likely to be hundreds, if not thousands, more skeletons resting in a temporal peace further along the street and beneath the wynds and lanes running east toward the Links. Bringing up the bodies has only just begun.

I left the Museum of Edinburgh and stepped back outside onto the hum of the Royal Mile to join tourists, politicians, students and shop-keepers in the land of the living. Edinburgh, the city of constantly negotiated dualities, the Gothic dark of  old town closes and the broad, sweeping terraces of the Georgian New Town; an extinct volcano in the Royal park and the Dynamic Earth museum celebrating enlightened advances in science; fur coat and nae knickers etc. All is often not as it first seems. This, after all, is the city where Robert Louis Stevenson based his Jekyll and Hyde characters on the real-life body-snatchers, Burke and Hare. Inside the vestry of South Leith Parish Church, next to the Coats of Arms of Mary of Guise and her daughter Mary Queen of Scots, there are a collection of iron helmets and batons used by the men who guarded graves from robbers.

I continued down the Canongate, past the Scottish Parliament, the Palace of Holyrood, Easter Road and eventually back into the guts of Leith. Walking the length of Constitution Street, I looked up and around to notice the presence of any change on the street. On this occasion, the addition of craft-bombed woollen stockings clothed the Burns statue and a new neighbour in my tenement stair could be seen framed by a lit window. I smiled too at the things that remain ever-familiar. A menacing gull hovered overhead with illicit chips dangling in its beak. And I remembered the stories– real or imagined- of how places like the Leith Corn Exchange (now Creative Exchange), Martin’s Bakery (now Perinos fish and chip shop) and the Grain Silo at the Docks (now derelict) all came into being on the street and inter-link with one another.

Like the rye that becomes flour that becomes bread, we are constantly warming and fermenting our ideas and our sense of place in the world, preparing to rise or fall when the time comes for unexpected or unwelcome change. We prove- prove ourselves to be strong and ready, resilient and adaptable. Ready for what will be added to the mix of history. Perhaps after the introduction to some of my street ancestors that lie beneath, I will cast my gaze down from time to time, toward the soil, sand and silt deep below and tap the ground gently with the sole of my foot in acknowledgement of never truly being alone. We are all part of a long line of human connection met comin’ thru the grain.

On the north wall of the Church, there is a sculpture commissioned in 2009 to commemorate all who are buried in Leith in unmarked graves. It features, in the shape of the Water of Leith river path, a text from 1 Corinthians, chapter 15:

When buried, ugly and weak;

When raised beautiful and strong.

When buried, a physical body;

When raised a spiritual body.

Advertisements

Little women

Richard III was a Neville. My great, great uncle Daniel was eaten by a crocodile. James Smith set sail from Timberbush, Leith, for The New World as a cabin boy and returned a wealthy sea merchant. All true, apparently.

I know these, and other heroic tales, to be true apparently, because of diaries and official records. Except that these accounts of ancestral history are incomplete because of their failure to adequately document the women in the protagonists’ lives.

James Smith wrote a whole tome entitled ‘The Book of Occurrences’ about his sea-faring world adventures but included little detail about the women that supported his rise to fame and fortune. I wonder what he would make of me now living back on Constitution Street, Leith, and writing about it occasionally. I know nothing about the women who might have mourned the unfortunate demise of Daniel after the croc. Wife of Richard (the one found in a Leicester carpark with a sore back)- Queen Anne Neville – gets a substantial bookmark in history but only in reference to her king-maker role in the War of the Roses (said to be the inspiration for the Game of Thrones hit series) and as a woman educated and wealthy enough to wield power and influence.

In less regal branches of extended family tree, women appear briefly in birth, marriage and death, if at all. And upon marriage, loose their maiden name and thus clues to their genealogical roots. Beyond two or three living generations, maternal lineage becomes harder to trace and female footsteps gradually fade into anonymity. Our record of history is the history of men. In retelling only that version of events, we all miss something.

And so it was with interest and gratitude that I have observed my grandmother and sister’s recent efforts to piece together the she-lines of our own family. Beginning by narrating her own mother (Stella)’s story, our grandmother (Isobel) painstakingly followed a line from daughter to mother back and back. Then with the help of the National Registrar of Scotland, church marriage records, pencil sketches, and great tenacity and patience, Isobel and Lucy managed to trace a path over eight generations and several previous Isobel/las, as far back as the 1740s and the Jacobite retreat through Perthshire when church records were burned. The faces staring out at us from subsequent faded photographs have now been given identities and reinstated into the permanence of the past; separate to their fathers, brothers and sons.

Margaret Jolly

Margaret Jolly (born 1841). She married James Barr, a sea captain and a nephew of author James Smith, his mother Isabella being a sister of James. The baby is Isabella Smith Barr (born 1870).

In praise of this and in response to International Womens’ Day, 8 March, I invited some of the women I most admire to come together for a meal and the sharing of stories about the women who have shaped our different life experiences thus far. I also asked each guest to consider what she had inherited, and what she might pass on, irrespective of whether that inheritance should be social or biological. These memories are of course for others to own and interpret as they wish to but I have attempted to gather together some of that which was retold.

We discussed the F-word with reference to classics such as Betty Freidan’s The Feminine Mystique and more contemporary writing including 50 Shades of Feminism and Caitlin Moran’s How to Be a Woman. We laughed and we cried. We talked about food, sex, and fashion. But mostly we just made time to honour the courageous, funny and talented women that have made us each who we are today.

Nina talked about her academic career teaching anti-discrimination law to students at Glasgow University. And she told us the story of how she got her name; of her mother’s best friend in Toronto, also Nina, and sadly no longer alive. She reflected that, for her, feminism is a connection to love.

On love, Isobel shared a morning mantra: “I love me. I am a being of love. I feel wonderful” and gifted each of us a postcard showing the heather and rolling hills of her native Galloway as a souvenir reminder of why self-respect and love must be the foundation for all relationships.

Isobel

Isobel Neville (nee Robertson) in the Galloway countryside, 1946

In turn, Rowena shared her admiration for Isobel via an email contribution sent from a remote village in Uganda where she was working at the time in gynaecology and family-planning medicine:

“I think of my two grandmothers. Both were brought up largely by their mothers, themselves independent women who overcame many challenges. They have a true spirit of adventure, which sees them continue to explore new places and take up new activities into their 80s. They are each lynchpins in their own large and geographically dispersed families, keeping us all in touch and together. Neither is overly sentimental, but is honest and straight talking, which can be so refreshing. They have both given me invaluable advice over the years and have both passed to me a love of the outdoors, of wide open spaces and fresh air.
Have a great day – I am helping to give a talk on the new cervical screening program being set up by the hospital here, before sodas and music :)”.

I embarrassed Isobel further by telling one of my favourite stories about her single-handedly taking on the might of corporate advertising and a multinational fashion brand, and quietly winning. She had spoken out about her distaste at seeing the mannequin dummies in Edinburgh’s Harvey Nicholls Department Store dressed in metal bondage chains. A polite but firm complaint that stated her objection to depicting women as slaves resulted in a rethink about visual merchandising, a complimentary lunch by way of apology, and perhaps a lesson in history for John Galliano.

Dee, while breastfeeding baby daughter Aoife, introduced us to a real-life ‘sister act’ – her great aunt Maur– a guitar-playing nun who studied at Trinity College Dublin and went onto win the university table tennis championship dressed in full habit and wimple. Maur had made the most of the limited choices available to her at the time outside of a married life.

Aoife

With Aoife Francis Neville, Perthshire, 2014

Wendy told us the story of how she came to learn to play piano in South Africa on a baby grand piano inherited from her great-grandmother (Florence Franzen). Wendy spoke of her favourite memories listening to her mother (Sharon) play while she (Wendy) was drifting off to sleep. One classical piece, by Zd. Fibich, was particularly poignant: Sharon had drawn comfort by learning and playing this piece in the months following her mother’s death (Hilda Ham). Some years ago, having acquired a piano in Scotland, Wendy decided to learn this piece – both to enjoy it for herself, and also as a way of honouring the tradition of women in her family. Being Wendy, she had also gone to the effort of recording a recital of the piece for us to listen to.

Tricia shared a smiling photograph of her mother, Sheila, dressed in dungarees and headscarf atop hay bales in the Land Army. She said: “The greatest pride in my life is that my daughters are not afraid to give their opinions. My mother, Sheila Menzies, was told from childhood until she was a young adult that her views were worthless and should not be expressed. That stayed with her all her life despite her being such a caring, intelligent woman. We have come a long way as a society to where we find ourselves today.”

Over the course of the last nine months since 8 March 2014, babies have been born, relationships ended and new ones begun, careers progressed, political campaigns won or lost, and more stories made. I hope the lunch becomes an annual event. Perhaps it has taken me so long to write up a record of that Saturday in March because the telling of women’s lives, throughout history, has largely been an oral tradition and not always a written one.

On researching International Women’s Day, I found this quote from the late human rights activist and trade union leader, Inez McCormack:

As soon as you get space as a woman, you should turn around and acknowledge the other women who came before you, and those who have yet to get out of the shadows and into the sun”. 

Some things only make sense with the settling of time and the perspective of context. Just as I’ve always been terrified of crocodiles, I know that I’m also a living mix of all the extraordinary, little women that came out of the shadows and into the sun before me. They didn’t need to colonize countries, battle wild animals or win wars to do so. They were carers and careerists, agriculturists and academics. And their individualism did not, in any way, diminish or threaten the love they had for the men in their lives. To acknowledge this inheritance, I plan to enjoy my space as a woman, celebrate a name of my own, and a rightful place in the next layer of genealogy.

@jemma_tweets